
Should you put a question mark after 'who knows?'
A while back, Los Angeles Times columnist Steve Lopez spent the night in a tent in front of City Hall to get the pulse of the local incarnation of the Occupy Wall Street protests.
He learned a lot, he said, but the experience still left some questions unanswered: “Will it grow into a cohesive movement? Who knows.”
I don’t know, either. But what I do know is that I stopped reading there. The period after “knows” got my attention. Lopez or his editors could have just as logically opted for a question mark. Yet the period won them over.
“Who knows” is a question, not a statement. So why no question mark?
There are two ways to look at this, both acceptable in professional publishing.
One way, as stated above, is summed up thusly: A question is a question is a question, and it takes a question mark. The other way to look at it is: Lopez wasn’t really asking. Thus, you could argue, it was a rhetorical question. And since he wasn’t asking anything, the question mark isn’t necessary.
Both interpretations are fine. But, personally, I prefer the former. A sentence structured as an interrogative – even if it doesn’t seek an answer -- has a different quality than does a declarative. Instead of “who knows,” Lopez could have said “no one knows” or “I doubt anyone knows,” both of which are structured as declaratives. But his choice of “who knows” conveys something different – a mystery, a riddle, a thing to be pondered. In other words, it has a questioning quality. And, after all, structurally it is a question.
Another question that’s often meant as a statement: “Why not?” I often see this written “Why not.” And why not? The writer isn't really seeking an answer, right? Well, I wasn’t seeking an answer to that “right,” either. Yet that clearly requires the question mark.
In fiction, many questions meant as statements end in periods.
Bad guy: “Get in the car.”
Hero: “And if I don’t.”
Bartender: “Here’s your drink, sir.”
Customer: “You call this a martini.”
Neither the Chicago Manual of Style nor the AP Stylebook addresses this matter directly. But Chicago includes an interesting note about “courtesy questions.” “A request courteously disguised as a question does not require a question mark.” An example: “Will the audience please rise.”
But the wording “does not require a question mark” suggests that the question mark may nonetheless apply.
Me, I’d put a question mark after all those – the hero’s, the customer’s, the request to rise, and even “who knows?”
But you don’t have to do it my way. Whenever you’re certain the question seeks no answer, you can choose for yourself. The question mark suggests that, if the sentence were spoken the speaker's voice would lilt up at some point to intone a question. The period suggest a flatter sound, which can help a fiction writer keep their tough guys from sounding like Valley girls.
Whatever you do, watch out for “Guess what.” This is not a question. It’s a command -- an imperative. And a question mark after “guess what” makes no sense at all.
I can only think of one example of a rhetorical question that I would not end with a question mark. It comes from an old Simpsons episode in which Homer is trying to guess how many roads a man must walk down before you can call him a man. “Seven!” he guesses.
Lisa: “No, Dad. It’s a rhetorical question.”
Homer, thinks about it a moment, then blurts out, “Eight!”
Lisa: “Dad, do you even know what rhetorical means?”
Homer: “Do I know what rhetorical means!”
Tags: COPY EDITING, GRAMMAR, PUNCTUATION, QUESTION MARK, WHO KNOWS
This entry was posted on Monday, March 1st, 2021 at 3:56 pm and is filed under Blog. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.


- #AMWRITING
- #SpellCheckCannotSaveYou
- A WHILE VS. AWHILE
- ABBREVIATIONS
- Acronym
- Acronym vs Initialism
- ACTION VERBS
- ACTIVE VOICE
- ACTUALLY
- ADJECTIVES
- ADRENALINE VS ADRENALIN
- ADVERBIAL
- ADVERBS
- ADVERSE AND AVERSE
- ADVISOR vs. ADVISER
- AESTHETIC AND ESTHETIC
- AFFECT AND EFFECT
- AGGRAVATE AND IRRITATE
- AGREEMENT
- ALRIGHT ALL RIGHT
- AMN'T
- AMONG
- AMPERSAND
- an historic
- AND
- AND I VS AND ME
- ANTONYMS
- anxious vs eager
- ANYMORE ANY MORE
- AP STYLE
- apostrophe
- apostrophe abuse
- APOSTROPHE IN LETTER GRADES
- Apostrophe in Mothers Day
- Apostrophe in Presidents Day
- Apostrophe in Veterans Day
- APOSTROPHE PROTECTION SOCIETY
- APOSTROPHES
- apostrophes for form plurals
- APPEARANCE SAKE
- APPOSITIVE
- AREN'T I
- AS WELL AS
- ASPECT
- ATTRIBUTIVE NOUN
- AUXILIARY VERB
- BAD ADVICE
- BAITED BREATH
- BEACH GOER OR BEACHGOER
- beg the question
- beginning a sentence with and
- beginning a sentence with but
- BEGINNING SENTENCE WITH AND
- BEGINNING SENTENCE WITH CONJUNCTION
- BEGINNING SENTENCE WITH PRONOUN
- ben zimmer
- BENJAMIN DREYER
- BETWEEN
- BETWEEN SENTENCES
- BETWEEN YOU AND I
- BETWEEN YOU AND ME
- bimonthly
- biweekly
- BOOK TITLES
- BOOK TITLES IN ITALICS
- BOOK TITLES IN QUOTATION MARKS
- BORED BY OR BORED OF OR BORED WITH
- BRING AND TAKE
- Bristol Punctuation Vigilante
- BRYAN GARNER
- BULLETED LISTS
- BURIED VERB
- CACHE
- CACHET
- CANNABUSINESS
- capitalization
- CHAISE LONGUE
- CHANUKAH
- CHOMPING AT THE BIT
- CHOOSING SPECIFIC NOUNS AND VERBS
- CITE and SIGHT
- CLARITY
- CLATFART
- COLLECTIVE NOUNS
- COLON
- COLON VS. SEMICOLON
- Colons
- comma
- COMMA AFTER INC
- COMMA AFTER STATE
- COMMA AFTER YEAR
- COMMA BEFORE A TITLE
- COMMA IN IS IS
- COMMA SPLICE
- COMMAS
- commas around inc.
- COMMAS BETWEEN ADJECTIVES
- commas between coordinate adjectives
- COMMAS INSIDE QUOTATION MARKS
- COMMON SPELLING ERRORS
- COMMONLY CONFUSED EXPRESSIONS
- COMMONLY CONFUSED WORDS
- COMPARATIVE
- COMPARATIVES
- comparatives and superlatives
- COMPLIMENT AND COMPLEMENT
- COMPOSE AND COMPRISE
- compound adjectives
- COMPOUND MODIFIER
- compound modifiers
- COMPOUND NOUN
- conjunctions
- CONJUNCTIVE LIKE
- CONTINUAL AND CONTINUOUS
- COPULAR VERBS
- copy editin
- COPY EDITING
- CORONAVIRUS SLANG
- COULD CARE LESS VS COULDN'T CARE LESS
- COULD OF and COULD HAVE
- COUPLE IS OR COUPLE ARE
- COVIDIOT
- DANGLER
- danglers
- DANGLING MODIFIER
- DANGLING PARTICIPLE
- dash
- DASH VS SEMICOLON
- DASH VS. COLON
- decimate
- decimate usage
- DECLARATIVE
- DECLARATIVE QUESTION
- DEFINITE ARTICLE
- DICTIONARIES
- DIFFERENT FROM VS DIFFERENT THAN
- DIRECT OBJECTS
- DISINTERESTED UNINTERESTED
- DISJUNCTS CONJUNCTS ADJUNCTS
- DO'S AND DON'TS
- done vs finished
- DOUBLE NEGATIVE
- DOUBLE POSSESSIVE
- DOUBLE SPACING
- DREAMED VS DREAMT
- DUMMY OPERATOR
- EASILY CONFUSED WORDS
- EDITING
- EFFETE
- EGGCORN
- ellipses
- EM DASHES
- EMAIL E-MAIL
- EMAIL GREETINGS
- EMIGRATE AND IMMIGRATE
- EN DASH VS EM DASH
- ENGLISH
- enormity
- ENSURE INSURE
- ETYMOLOGY
- EVACUATE
- EVERY DAY VS. EVERYDAY
- EXCLAMATION POINT
- EXISTENTIAL THERE
- FALSE RANGES
- FARTHER
- father's day
- faulty parallel
- FAULTY SENTENCE STRUCTURE
- FAZE and PHASE
- FIVE BASIC SENTENCE STRUCTURES
- FLAT ADVERBS
- FLESH OUT AND FLUSH OUT
- FOR CONSCIENCE SAKE
- FOR GOODNESS SAKE
- FORGO AND FORGO
- FORGO FOREGO
- FORGONE FOREGONE
- FORM TYPES OF VERBS
- FORWENT FOREWENT
- FRAUGHT VS FRAUGHT WITH
- FRIEND OF
- FURTHER
- Fused Participle
- GAUNTLET GANTLET
- GENERIC PRONOUN ONE
- GOOD AND WELL
- GOOD VS WELL
- GOODNESS SAKE
- GRADUATE COLLEGE OR GRADUATE FROM COLLEGE
- GRAMMAR
- GRAMMAR CHECKER
- GRAMMAR MYTH
- grammar peeves
- grammar phobia
- GRAMMAR TERMS
- GRAMMATICAL MOOD
- GREAT AND WELL
- GREATLY
- GREETING
- GROGNARD
- HANGED VS HUNG
- HANUKKAH
- HARSH WRITING ADVICE
- HAVE GOT
- HE OR HIM
- HEALTHCARE VS HEALTH CARE
- HEALTHFUL
- HEALTHY
- HELTER SKELTER
- HISTORIC VS HISTORICAL
- HOME IN VS HONE IN
- HOMONYMS
- HOMOPHONES AND HOMOGRAPHS
- HOPEFULLY
- HOW TO WRITE
- HOW TO WRITE BOOK TITLES
- how to write holidays
- HOW TO WRITE MOVIE TITLES
- HYPHEN
- HYPHENATING NOUNS
- HYPHENATING PREFIXES AND SUFFIXES
- HYPHENATING SUFFIXES
- HYPHENATING VERBS
- hyphenation
- hyphens
- I FEEL BAD VS I FEEL BADLY
- I vs Me
- IDIOMS
- if and whether
- immigrate emigrate migrate
- IMPERATIVE
- imperatives
- IMPORTANTLY
- INDEFINITE PRONOUNS
- INDEXES INDICES
- INDIRECT OBJECT
- INDIRECT OBJECT PRONOUN
- insure vs ensure
- INTERROGATIVE
- INTO VS IN TO
- INTRANSITIVE VERBS
- INTRUSIVE OF
- IRREGARDLESS AND REGARDLESS
- IRREGULAR NOUNS
- IS IS
- ITALICS
- ITS AND IT'S
- JACOB REES-MOGG
- JOB TITLES
- john dowd
- John Le Carre
- JOHN MCINTYRE
- JONATHON OWEN
- Journalism Standards
- KORY STAMPER
- LANGUAGE
- LAY AND LIE
- LAY IN STATE
- LESS THAN
- less vs fewer
- LET'S AND LETS
- LET'S EAT GRANDMA
- LEXICOGRAPHY
- LIE IN STATE
- lighted vs lit
- LIKE
- LIKE AND AS
- LIKE AND SUCH AS
- LINKING VERBS
- LITERALLY
- LOAN VS LEND
- LOG IN VS LOGIN
- MAJORITY
- MANAFORT
- MANIKIN MANNEQUIN
- MANNER ADVERBS
- MARY NORRIS
- MAY VS. MIGHT
- MERRIAM
- METACONCEPTS
- MIKE POMPEO
- MODAL AUXILIARY
- MODALITY
- modifying phrases
- MOOD
- MORE THAN
- MOST COMMON APOSTROPHE ERRORS
- MOST COMMON GRAMMAR ERRORS
- Most common grammar mistakes
- mother's day
- MOVIE TITLES
- MYRIAD VS A MYRIAD OF
- MYSELF
- MYSELF VS. ME
- NAMES
- NATIONAL GRAMMAR DAY
- NEEDLESS WORDS
- NEOLOGISMS
- NEVER MIND / NEVERMIND
- NEW WORDS
- NEW YEAR'S
- no problem
- NOMINALIZATIONS
- NONBINARY THEY
- NONCE WORD
- NONE IS VS NONE ARE
- NONPLUSSED
- NONRESTRICTIVE CLAUSES
- NOUNS ENDING IN S
- object complement
- OBJECT PRONOUN
- OBJECT PRONOUNS
- OBJECTS AND SUBJECTS
- obscenity
- OED
- OK OKAY
- ONE SPACE
- ONLY
- ONTO VS ON TO
- OR
- OVER
- OVER AND UNDER
- oxford comma
- OXFORD ENGLISH DICTIONARY
- PALETTE PALATE PALLET
- PALM OFF VS. PAWN OFF
- PARALLEL STRUCTURE
- PARENTHESES
- PARTICIPIAL PHRASES
- PARTS OF SPEECH
- PASSIVE VOICE
- past participles
- past tense
- PAST TENSE OF LAY
- PAST TENSE OF SLAY
- period before a quotation mark
- PERIODS IN INITIALS
- PERIODS INSIDE QUOTATION MARKS
- PERUSE
- PETER SOKOLOWSKI
- PHRASAL VERBS
- PIQUE
- placement of only
- plead pled
- PLURAL
- PLURAL OF ATTORNEYS GENERAL
- PLURAL POSSESSIVE
- PLURAL POSSESSIVES
- PLURAL POSSESSIVES OF PROPER NOUNS
- PLURAL VERB
- PLURAL VERB WITH AS WELL AS
- PLURAL VERBS
- PLURALS
- PLURALS OF LATIN WORDS
- PLURALS OF LETTERS
- PLURALS OF MOVIE TITLES
- POSSESSIVE
- Possessive with Gerund
- possessives
- POSSESSIVES OF MOVIE TITLES
- POSSESSIVES OF PROPER NAMES
- PREDICATE NOMINATIVE
- prefixes
- PREPOSI
- PREPOSITIONS
- PRESCRIPTIVISM
- PREVENTATIVE
- PREVENTIVE
- PRINCIPAL AND PRINCIPLE
- PRINCIPLE and PRINCIPAL
- profanity
- PRONOUN ANTECEDENT AGREEMENT
- PRONOUNS
- pronunciation of often
- proofreading
- PUNCTUATION
- QUASI COORDINATOR
- QUASI POSSESSIVES
- QUESTION MARK
- quotation marks
- raise the question
- REDUPLICATIVE COPULA
- REFLEXIVE PRONOUNS
- REFLEXIVES
- REIN vs REIGN
- RELATIVE PRONOUN ANTECEDENT AGREEMENT
- RESTRICTIVE CLAUSES
- ROB AND BURGLARIZE
- ROCK N ROLL
- RUN-ON SENTENCES
- RUTH BADER GINSBURG
- SCARE QUOTES
- SEMICOLON
- SEMICOLON ABUSE
- SEMICOLONS
- semimonthly
- semiweekly
- SENTENCE ADVERBS
- sentence diagramming
- SENTENCE ENDING PREPOSITION
- SENTENCE ENDING PREPOSITIONS
- SENTENCE FRAGMENT
- SENTENCE STRUCTURES
- SENTENCE WRITING
- SENTENCES
- serial comma
- SHARED POSSESSIVE
- SHARED POSSESSIVES
- SIMPLE COMPOUND AND COMPLEX SENTENCES
- SINGLE QUOTATION MARK
- SINGULAR AUSPICE
- SINGULAR VERB
- SINGULAR VS PLURAL
- SITE
- SKUNKED TERMS
- SMIZE
- SNEAK PEAK VS SNEAK PEEK
- SNEAK VS. SNUCK VS. SNEAKED
- SO
- spaces around ellipses
- SPEECH TAGS
- spell check fail
- SPELL-CHECKER
- SPELLING
- SPITTING IMAGE
- split infinitive
- SQUINTING MODIFIER
- STARTING A SENTENCE WITH AND
- STEPHEN CALK
- STYLE
- STYLE GUIDES
- SUBJECT PRONOUNS
- SUBJECT VERB AGREEMENT
- SUBJECT-COMPLEMENT AGREEMENT
- SUBJECT-OBJECT AGREEMENT
- SUBJUNCTIVE
- SUBORDINATE CLAUSES
- SUBORDINATING CONJUNCTIONS
- suffixes
- SYNONYMS
- TENSE SHIFTS
- terminal punctuation
- THANKSGIVING DAY
- THAT AND WHICH
- THAT VS. WHICH
- THE JOY OF SYNTAX
- The Possessive of Jr.
- THE REASON IS BECAUSE
- THE REASON WHY
- THE WIRE
- THERE ARE
- THERE IS
- THERE'S
- THESE ONES
- THEY'RE AND THEIR
- THIS IS SHE
- THRU THROUGH
- TILL TIL UNTIL
- TITLED VS ENTITLED
- TITLES IN ITALICS
- TITLES IN QUOTATION MARKS
- TRANSITIVE
- TRANSITIVE VERBS
- TRUMP SPELLING
- TRUMP TWEET
- TRY AND
- TRY TO
- TWO SPACE
- TYPOS
- UNCLEAR ANTECEDENTS
- UNDERWAY / UNDER WAY
- UNNECESSARY ADVERBS
- USAGE
- VAGUE WORDS
- VERB CONJUGATION
- VERB TENSES
- VERBS
- veterans day
- VIS-A-VIS
- vocabulary
- WAS VS WERE
- WEBSTER'S NEW WORLD
- WEIRDEST LANGUAGES
- WELLBEING
- WERE VS WAS
- What Does Hoi Pollio Mean
- When to Capitalize After a Colon
- WHEN TO HYPHENATE PREFIXES
- WHILE VS ALTHOUGH
- WHO AND WHOM
- WHO KNOWS
- who vs whom
- WHOA WOAH WHOAH
- whom
- whomever
- WHOSE AND WHO'S
- WITH VS. OF
- WORD CHOICE
- WORD USAGE
- WRITING
- WRITING BOOKS
- WRITING CRAFT
- WRITING FOR CLARITY
- WRITING SKILLS
- WRITING STYLE
- WRITING TIPS
- ZERO RELATIVE PRONOUN
search
podcast
Ad Podcast to your site
A Pearson product. Copyright © 2011 Pearson Education, Inc. All rights reserved. Legal Notice | Privacy Policy | Permissions